The Ice Box is closed.
Thank you to our loyal customers!

We appreciate your business and wish you well.

Thank you so much for being part of the Ice Box family! Your support meant the world to us and we still hope to see you around the island. Please stop by and visit us at the Tisbury Toy Box next door!

  • Brownies and cookies for sundaes, cookie sandwiches, or just to munch on their own — straight from our ovens on the premises
  • Custom cones — waffle cones, sprinkle cones, and hand-dipped chocolate cones created by us to make your ice cream even tastier
  • Homemade toppings — hot fudge and whipped cream made from scratch
  • Slices of pie à la mode with Pie Chicks homemade pies and Ice Box ice cream, or yummy pie shakes that you must taste to believe!

Stop by for cones, cups, frappes, sundaes, cookie sandwiches, and more!

Want to get in touch? Email us at iceboxmv@gmail.com, or call us at (508) 693-8182 (we share that number with the Tisbury Toy Box). We hope to see you at the Ice Box soon!

Ice Box team at opening

Here's our flavor list, updated today (available in cones, cups, sundaes, milk shakes, on pie slices, and by the pint)

Check out our most popular flavors, updated daily

Cookies & Cream
Salted Caramel Truffle
Toasted Coconut
Snickerdoodle
Chocolate Lovers
Vanilla Bean
Strawberry
Pistachio
Chocolate Chip
Coffee
Birthday Cake
Mint Chip
Black Raspberry
Moose Tracks
Butter Pecan
Peanut Butter
Rocky Road
Rainbow Sherbet
Mango Sorbet
Lemon Sorbet
Flavors menu

While you're at the Ice Box, pick up our homemade brownies and chocolate chip cookies, made fresh on the premises.

Brownie packaging Cookie packaging

Here's what our customers think of Ice Box ice cream.

…and our new pie shakes.

Store interior Specialty cones Brownies Ice Box menu

Stop by and check us out!

The Ice Box • 79 Beach Road • Vineyard Haven, MA. 02568 • (508) 693-8182

Map to Ice Box at Tisbury Market Place